Category Archives: Latest News

Seismic Surveys for gas and oil off our coastline

Do you care about the marine life off the Plett/Knysna coastline?

What is happening?

A company called Sungu-Sungu has been given a permit by the Petroleum Agency South Africa to do seismic surveys for gas and oil off our coastline. Quite apart from the eventual implications of any future drilling and exploitation, the seismic surveys themselves could severely affect the marine life off our shores, since their surveys are conducted with ship-based air guns that produce sound levels of about 280 decibels (in humans, sounds louder than 85 decibels can cause hearing loss).

What can I do?

You, the public, have until 15 June 2017 to comment and register your protest in terms of the Environmental Impact Report (EIA) that is taking place right now.

If you care about our marine life, take a few minutes to send in an email with comments to:

Wanda Marais: SRK Consulting
PO Box 21842, Port Elizabeth, 6000
Tel: +27 41 509 4800
Email: wmarais@srk.co.za

Before 15 June.

Use the following subject heading in your email: 3D Seismic Survey in the Pletmos Basin, Southern Cape. SRK Project Number 510482.

What do I say?

We are making it easy for you as member of the public to make sensible comments on what is quite a technical issue. The background, tips on what to say and meaningful comments that can be made are set out below. This informational piece has been prepared for the Plett community on behalf of the Plettenberg Bay Community Environmental Forum by Polly Bramham, the Forum’s permanent consultant; Dr Gwenith Penry, a marine life expert; and Dr Mark Brown, director of the Nature’s Valley Trust.

Who can comment?

We encourage as many members of the public, organised groups, non-profit organisations, businesses and any other interested parties to submit comments to Wanda Marais at the address above. You do not need to be an expert to make meaningful comments.

Brief Background

This proposed seismic survey is part of Operation Phakisa, run by the Department of Environmental Affairs and designed to maximise the economic potential of our oceans.

The program is wide-ranging and covers improved tourism ventures, small-scale fishing cooperatives, increased protection of key areas through the proclamation of new marine protected areas, as well as exploring with a view to offshore mining. The seismic survey relates to the latter.

Almost the whole coast (except marine protected areas) is open for exploration by mining companies, who apply for permits to do so.

We want to outline the key issues that should be raised. We trust these will help you to submit comments that add weight to the opposition against this type of survey taking place off our Plett/Knysna coastline.

The letters of objection must be aimed at the actual 3D seismic surveying process, which forms the basis of this current Environmental Impact Assessment.

3D seismic surveys are conducted to acquire data on the subsea environment by using sound waves, and are used to understand the nature and extent of any oil and gas reserves in the area. The oil and gas industry uses this information to determine the economic viability of further exploration and development activities.

The current process is restricted to the seismic survey activities and does not embrace any drilling and production activities.

If deposits were to be found, and before drilling starts, the environmental consulting company working for Sungu-Sungu will have to submit a whole new Environmental Impact Assessment, and there will be further opportunities for public comment.

There are two issues we should all be commenting on:

1.    Our opposition to the 3D seismic survey, and
2.    ensuring that the mitigation measures proposed in the Environmental Impact Assessment report are adhered to if the survey does go ahead (equally important).

General tips

•    While you may be strongly opposed to offshore drilling, oil rigs, and other activities and infrastructure associated with the exploration and possible production of oil and gas off our coastline, restrict your comments to the seismic survey, otherwise your comments will be considered inappropriate and be ignored. That is just the way the process works.

•    Comments should focus on the seismic survey Environmental Impact Assessment. At least read the summary document provided by SRK Consulting if you have the time (see http://www.srk.co.za/en/za-sungu-sungu-pletmos-seismic-eia ).

•    Lengthy submissions carry no more weight than short bullet point submissions, so don’t feel you have to write essays. Keep it simple, to the point and relevant, to ensure it is counted as a valid submission.

What to include in your comments

Your main comment should be that you oppose the seismic survey, and support the No Go alternative (which means “No survey”). Make the following comments to validate this:

•    Disruptive seismic activity is in direct conflict with the ’sense of place’ that has been created for the marine environment of the Garden Route.

•    The exploration zone falls within an area which is dependent on tourism and fishing, both of which are likely to be disrupted by the proposed work. Any impact on these activities should be avoided. A three-month period of disruption would severely impact our town.

•    Seismic surveys so close to two Marine Protected Areas (Tsitsikamma and Robberg) conflict directly with the Department of Environmental Affairs’ own conservation priorities for this area.

•    The area of the survey is directly alongside an international Marine Hope Spot with Mission Blue International (one of only six in Africa), which highlights Plett marine biodiversity as being of global significance for marine conservation.

•    The surveys are close to an International Bird & Biodiversity Area, based on rigid global criteria used by Birdlife International to highlight globally significant areas for bird conservation.

•    The high number of threatened, endangered or data deficient species present in the region requires further study before any high impact surveys such as seismic surveys are done. These species include the Bryde’s whale, humpback whale, southern right whale, killer whale, bottlenose dolphin, common dolphin, humpback dolphin, great white shark, blue shark, mako shark, African penguin, Cape cormorant, and Cape gannet.

•    At present, we have no idea how the survey will affect local fish stocks, particularly bait fish stocks that support the food chain higher up.

Humpback whales are likely to occur in the exploration area. ©Gwen Penry.

What if it goes ahead despite our comments?

There is a chance that, despite our comments, the seismic survey may go ahead. If this does happen, we must make sure that the mitigation measures identified in the Environmental Impact Assessment report are implemented effectively in the survey to ensure minimum damage to the marine biodiversity in our region.

This is our only opportunity to influence how the survey is conducted, so unless we all comment on, and highlight the importance of the mitigation measures, they do not have to listen to what we say if it does go ahead.

Comments to be made on the seismic survey methods

•    The proposed timing (February- May) coincides with the northward migration of small pelagic fish and the numerous predators that follow this migration (sharks, birds, predatory fish, dolphins, whales). This is exactly when these fish are off the coast between Knysna and Jeffrey’s Bay. We suggest the July-September period would represent less of a risk to the local biodiversity. By this time, most of the fish should be well north of the exploration area, humpback whale numbers should be relatively low and southern right whales will be inshore or further west. The Environmental Impact Assessment focuses on mitigation measures for migratory whales, but does not account properly for resident whales, such as Bryde’s whales, and migrating fish.

•    We urge the authorities and the proponent to confirm and ensure that should the seismic surveys proceed, all mitigation measures will be adhered to, specifically regarding marine mammals. These mitigation measures have been detailed in the EIA report.

•    We urge the authorities and the proponent to ensure that the Petroleum Agency South Africa implement all recommended mitigation measures as mandatory, and ensure strict compliance with these measures.

•    All data collected by the onboard observers on seabirds, turtles, squid and marine mammals should be made available to researchers working in the area.

•    Full disclosure and information on the company who will be conducting the survey and their Environmental Management Plan and contingency plans should be provided. This includes the total amount in Rands available to deal with disasters such as fuel spills, entanglement in seismic gear, and mass strandings of marine mammals.

•    In the executive summary of the EIA report, page 5 Section 5.3, information is provided on Operational Emissions and Discharges. We have several concerns relating to the vague description of how waste will be handled. The wording in the last point states; ‘General and hazardous waste will generally be collected in waste skips …’

This is not satisfactory and we insist that ALL hazardous waste, sewerage and drainage or ballast water that contains contaminants MUST NOT be disposed of at sea. This is due to the proximity to two marine protected areas, for which such disposal could be catastrophic.

•    The proponents and the company undertaking the seismic survey must notify Interested and Affected Parties (which will include YOU if you comment) of the start date of the survey so that research and monitoring of possible impacts can be conducted.

We trust you find this summary useful in compiling your comments. Remember to submit via email by 15th June – not to me, but to Wanda Marais of SRK Consulting, whose details were provided earlier on. Also, send this email to all your friends and ask them to comment as well.

September 2015

Skiboat club advert

Fishing:

September 2015 Fishing League will take place on Saturday the 26th of September at first light. Scales close at 15h00.

Rugby World Cup:

We will be screening all the games and running specials on the following:

  • 19th September 2015 South Africa vs Japan kick off at 16:45
  • 26th September 2015 South Africa vs Samoa kick off at 16:45
  • 3rd October 2015 South Africa vs Samoa kick off at 16:45
  • 7th October 2015 South Africa vs USA kick off at 16:45

Lots of fun, lots of drink specials, guess the winning team and win, braais, boerewors and rugby – nothing better!

Plett on a Platter:

  • 24th September 2015 – Heritage Day Braai from noon:
  • Angel Fish, Dorado and Tuna Kebabs with salads @ R90-00 per person
  • Sirloin and Chicken Kebabs with salads @ R90-00 per person
  • 25th September 2015 – “A taste of the ocean” mini seafood platter at R90-00 per person.
  • Non-members welcome

Plett Ski Boat 16.9.15

South Africa’s hake fishery is sustainable and well managed

Media release 27 May 2015

South Africa’s hake fishery is sustainable and well managed 

The 51 trawler owners and operators in South Africa’s Deep Sea Trawling Industry Association (SADSTIA) yesterday received word that the Marine Stewardship Council (MSC) has approved a further five-year certification for the deep-sea trawl fishery.

SADSTIA’s members are the trawler owners and operators that deliver hake to fish & chip shops in every corner of South Africa; process and package fish fingers and other popular hake products for local supermarkets; and also supply a demanding international market with a range of value-added hake products.

“The certification is an important achievement for the deep-sea fishery and very good news for South Africa,” said Dr Johann Augustyn, secretary of SADSTIA.

“Recent economic studies have shown that securing the health of the deep-sea fishery has prevented the loss of up to 12 000 jobs within the fishing industry and growing demand (particularly in northern Europe) for certified sustainable seafood products has resulted in the expansion of export markets worth US$197 million (R2.24 billion).”

According to Tim Reddell, chairman of SADSTIA and a director of Viking Fishing, one of the advantages of holding MSC certification is that it has made trawler owners and operators more aware of the ways in which their vessels and operations interact with the environment.

“It has focused our attention on ensuring that we achieve the criteria of sustainable utilisation of the resource,” says Reddell.

This is the third time the hake trawl fishery has secured certification from the MSC, the world’s leading certification and eco-labelling program for sustainable wild-caught seafood. In 2004 it became the first hake fishery in the world to be judged by the MSC as “sustainable and well managed”; after the initial five-year certification period came to an end in 2009, the fishery was re-assessed and re-certified for a five-year period in 2010. The latest certification comes after a rigorous 12-month re-assessment process during which an independent certification agency scrutinised every aspect of the fishery’s management and once again found it to comply with the MSC’s main principles. These are:

  • a fishery is conducted in such a way that it does not lead to over fishing or a decrease in the stock;
  • fishing operations do not impact on the health of the marine ecosystem;
  • fishing is managed and regulated in a responsible way.

Since the initial MSC certification in 2004, improved fishing practices have resulted in major environmental achievements. For instance:

  • Trawl grounds have been “ring fenced” so as to prevent damage to lightly trawled areas and protect natural refuges for hake. Trawling outside the ring fenced zone requires an environmental impact assessment.
  • There has been a 99% reduction in the number of albatrosses that are accidentally injured and sometimes killed by trawl gear.
  • Bycatch (species other than hake that are caught in trawl nets, including kingklip and monk) is better managed than ever before.
  • The industry is funding and supporting a ground-breaking, long-term research project that will examine the impacts of trawling on the marine environment. The research is being conducted in partnership with the Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, the University of Cape Town and the South African Environmental Observation Network.

South Africa’s deep-sea trawl fishery is the only fishery in Africa to have achieved accreditation from the MSC. It is one of approximately 250 fisheries around the world that have been certified by the MSC. Together, MSC-certified fisheries currently catch about nine million metric tonnes of seafood annually – close to 10% of the total harvest from wild capture fisheries.

 

Read the MSC public certification report here: https://www.msc.org/track-a-fishery/fisheries-in-the-program/certified/south-atlantic-indian-ocean/south-africa-hake-trawl-fishery/south-african-hake-second-reassessment-documents/20150526_PCR_HAK108.pdf

 

Issued by SADSTIA 27 May 2015

For more information please contact:

  1. Dr Johann Augustyn, secretary of SADSTIA

Email: johann@sadstia.co.za

Tel: 082 8293911

  1. Mr Tim Reddell, chairman of SADSTIA and director of Viking Fishing

Email: tim@selectafish.co.za

Tel: 082 8084000

 

For more information on SADSTIA: www.sadstia.co.za

For more information on the Marine Stewardship Council: www.msc.org

For more information on the ring fence initiative; seabird mitigation measures and benthic research: http://www.sadstia.co.za/index.php/news news

Riley to Captain Protea Fishing Team to Compete in World Championships in Brazil

Plett resident, Mike Riley has been selected to captain the Protea Fishing Team to represent South Africa in the 23rd World Championship Big Game Fishing Trolling to be held in Vitoria, Brazil from 22nd to 29th November. The other 3 members of the Proteas team are: Danie Visser (Mpumalanga); Jaco Hendriksz (Gauteng) and Janes Wasserman (Gauteng).

This is Riley’s second Proteas cap. Last year, Riley was a member of the team that finished in second place at the EFSA (European Federation of Sea Anglers) championships hosted in Cabo San Lucas, Mexico. Riley a member of the Plettenberg Bay Ski Boat Club for 32 years is delighted at being nominated as team captain: “I am extremely honoured to be representing my Country on this prestigious stage. I have received tremendous encouragement and support from many people, however it is important that I acknowledge John Pledger – President of SASCOC, a friend, and one of my most positive supporters; and Ted Horn together with Big Team, without whose sponsorship and mentorship I would not have achieved this personal career highlight” said Riley.

“We are looking forward to the competition and to proudly representing South Africa. We hope that the fishing is going to be excellent and that we can bring home some of the prizes.”

The competition is open to all classes of tackle and is an all-release competition. All catches are recorded by electronic equipment and points are awarded according to species caught.